Last Thursday, I had a deep conversation with James, a high-potential executive with aspirations to start a personal development coaching business. As we discussed his goals and challenges, our dialogue highlighted a highly insightful discussion related to how we can get the best results out of experience sharing and personal learning.
James, an aspiring entrepreneur, was stepping into an uncharted territory. With no prior experience in business startups, he faced the challenge of building a new career from scratch. There are a lot of learning gaps he needs to fill in terms of developing an effective business plan and implementation strategy. This is where the conventional wisdom of coaching—that one should strictly not give advice—meets a practical challenge.Â
Drawing upon my mentoring and business experience, I shared stories of my own successes and failures, not just to guide James but to alert him to many of the potential blind spots that he might face. In particular, how he can develop his sales channels and business network in the shortest time. The approach of combining direct advice coupled with challenging facilitation turned our session into an effective process of self-discovery and exploration.
On reflection, I asked James after our coaching/mentoring session if he thought a purely facilitative approach would have yielded the same or better results. His response was quite telling: "From my personal perspective, I feel it is almost impossible to ask someone to come up with an answer if he has no prior knowledge on the subject."
Research has supported our experience.
According to a study in the Journal of Applied Psychology, effective coaching involves an adaptive blend of both mentoring and facilitating. It suggests that while empowerment through self-generated solutions is critical, there are times when direct advice based on experience significantly enhances learning and development.
This dual approach is not just about solving immediate problems; it is about building a strong bondage between a person’s current state of readiness and their future potential. As Benjamin Disraeli once said, "The greatest good you can do for another is not just to share your riches but to reveal to them their own." This encapsulates the essence of transformational coaching — it is a dance between showing the path and empowering the person to try things on their own with supported encouragement.
From my experience, I have learned that a one-size-fits-all methodology often falls far short of addressing individual-specific needs. Each person’s background is unique, not just in their challenges but also in how they absorb and react to guidance. Thus, a versatile, multi-pronged approach not only enhances adaptability but also enriches the self-discovery journey.
As we evolve in our roles as coaches and mentors, let us embrace the complexity of human potential and the diverse tools at our disposal. Let us strive to unlock not just the capabilities but also the inherent wisdom of the people we guide. The true reward of coaching lies in witnessing their transformative journey, as they turn insight into action and aspirations into achievements.
I would like to hear your thoughts on this article so that we can further enhance our skills as an effective coach.
Comments